Mastering Restaurant Costs – Part 4: Turn Cost Data Into Smart Menu Decisions
- Info (Kitxens.com)
- 8 hours ago
- 4 min read
Every menu tells a story, but is yours telling the one that actually grows your business? The answer lies in the numbers you're already collecting. It's time to use them.
Knowing your costs is essential. Tracking them in real time gives you control. Managing inventory keeps your operation grounded. But none of that matters if the dishes you sell every day don’t reflect your actual numbers.
Your menu isn’t just a collection of food, it’s your frontline business strategy. It’s where margin meets marketing, where data meets guest behavior. And yet, too many restaurants operate with profitable operations and unprofitable menus.
In this fourth installment, we go beyond cost tracking and dive into how to use that data to make smarter, more profitable menu decisions. If you want to grow without guessing, this is the turning point.
Your menu is not fixed. It’s a live business tool.
Most restaurants treat their menu like a static document: you create it, you print it, and you try to make it work. But the most profitable operators treat their menu as a living, evolving tool that adapts to margins, ingredient prices, customer behavior, and strategic positioning.
Updating your menu doesn’t just mean removing the underperformers. It means analyzing the data beneath your dishes and using it to make strategic, revenue-driven decisions.
Menu profitability mapping: your baseline diagnostic
Using your recipe costing sheets, COGS data, and itemized sales, classify each dish according to its performance:
Menu Item Type | High Profit | Low Profit |
High Popularity | ⭐ Star – Promote more, feature as a signature dish | 🐴 Workhorse – Bundle or optimize portion/cost |
Low Popularity | 💎 Hidden Gem – Rebrand or reposition | 🐶 Dog – Remove or replace strategically |
Use this matrix as your monthly menu health check. It helps you go beyond opinion and make data-driven decisions.
Star (High Profit + High Popularity)
These are your best dishes.
They sell well and are very profitable.
Action: Promote them even more, make them the face of your brand, upsell them, highlight them on the menu.
Workhorse (Low Profit + High Popularity)
These dishes sell a lot, but don’t make you much money per plate.
They’re like a dependable workhorse: they carry a lot of your volume but don’t bring much margin.
Action: Try to optimize them—reduce portion size, renegotiate ingredient cost, bundle with high-margin sides.
Hidden Gem (High Profit + Low Popularity)
These dishes have significant margins but are not ordered often.
Action: Reposition or rebrand them. They may need a better name, description, or visual cue to draw attention.
Dog (Low Profit + Low Popularity)
These are the weakest performers.
They don’t sell well, and when they do, they don’t make you much money.
Action: Consider removing or replacing them. Sometimes they dilute your kitchen efficiency and menu clarity.
So to clarify:
Workhorse = sells a lot but brings low margin → tweak it, don’t eliminate.
Dog = doesn’t sell and has bad margins → remove or replace.
Example: Your birria tacos have a 28% food cost and sell 60 times a week. That’s a star—highlight it in color, recommend it verbally, and upsell it in combo deals. Meanwhile, your octopus ceviche sells only twice a week and has a 44% food cost. That’s a dog—either rework the price/portion or retire it.
Redesign your menu with intent and pricing psychology.
With your mapping complete, now you can shape the menu around what actually works—and gently guide guests to make choices that boost your profitability.
Menu design tactics to apply:
Position high-margin items in focal zones (top-right or center for printed menus)
Use bolder visuals and highlighted boxes to draw attention to Stars.
Employ price anchoring by placing a high-ticket item nearby to make your ideal dish look like a better deal.
Offer “menu bundles” that package a workhorse item with a low-cost, high-margin add-on (e.g., dessert, drink, side)
Remove noise. Eliminate low-performing dishes that distract or confuse the guest journey.
Remember: fewer choices = faster decisions = higher conversion.
What about price increases? Use data, not fear.
With real COGS data, you can raise prices with confidence—not guesswork. Focus on:
High-volume dishes with low price sensitivity
Incremental changes (no more than 5–10% at a time)
Pairing price increases with visible value (e.g., new plating, ingredient upgrade, faster prep)
Example: A burger joint increases its $10.95 smashburger to $11.50 after ground beef costs rise. Sales remain strong, and the added margin allows them to offer house-made pickles and compostable packaging—improving both quality and sustainability.
Train your team on the data behind the dish.
Even the most innovative pricing strategy can fail if your team doesn’t understand it. Share the “why” behind your menu updates to ensure alignment from kitchen to table.
How to do it: most innovative
Review the new menu map at a team meeting.
Assign roles: who promotes what, who prepares what, and what to push in upsell conversations.
Share wins: show staff how small changes in dish focus or delivery lead to better tips, better reviews, or smoother service.
Make it part of the culture: cost-aware teams think more like owners.
Final Reflection
You already have the data. You’ve been collecting it through POS, invoices, prep sheets, and sales. What’s missing is the transformation of that data into action—into a menu that sells strategically, scales operationally, and supports your vision for growth.
Great restaurants aren’t just built in the kitchen. They’re built in the systems, the math, and the menu.
Your guests will keep choosing. The only question is: are you guiding their decisions… or guessing what they’ll pick?
Comments